Why a Good Boss Can't Save You From a Bad Job

"People don't leave bad jobs; they leave bad bosses." (Or so the saying goes.) But what happens when the job is bad, but your boss is great?

If you've stayed somewhere longer than you should have because your manager was the one good thing about the role, you know the feeling. The commiserating, the sense that the two of you were in it together. Leaving might feel like abandoning the person who made everything tolerable.

But tolerable and worth staying for are two different things, and knowing the line between the two is how you protect your career.

Can a good boss make up for a bad job?

There's no doubt that a good boss can make a world of difference at a job. Whether it's making a bad situation better, acting as a sounding board, or advocating up the food chain on your behalf. They're supportive, skilled leaders who create a positive and productive work environment.

I got along really well with one of my former bosses. She was the ultimate listening ear. I could complain to her about anything and talk about my dreams for improving the situation. She provided mentorship and helped me climb the ranks within the company.

But at the end of the day, a great boss has to be more than a work friend. You may like your boss, but that doesn't mean your boss is a good boss. Or, your boss's hands are tied, and they don't have the power to enact real change in a bad environment.

In these situations, friend-bosses might make the job palatable, but they don't offset other factors that make the job a bad job.

Signs your boss can't save you from the job

Your boss might be doing everything they can with the influence they have. Problems may exist well above their pay grade. Other problems won't resolve on their own, and they usually have to do with the company's core essence of "this is who we are and what we do."

1. The company has bad leadership

Not all people who hold leadership roles are cut out to be leaders. Some lead out of ego, and others fail upwards into a role. If the CEO holds too much power to single-handedly dictate the company's path, that's a bad sign.

The iHire Toxic Workplace Trends Report found that poor leadership is the leading cause of toxic workplaces at almost 79%. Employees reported unethical, unaccountable, or unsupportive company leaders.

Poor leadership can lead to things like mass layoffs, and if that happens, your boss can’t protect you. (In fact, your boss might even be impacted, as managers are frequently a target of layoffs.)

Look at communication from the c-suite and ask yourself whether you know where the company is headed.

2. You have toxic colleagues

Toxicity isn’t only at the c-suite level. Leadership might be fine, but you have toxic colleagues. Your boss may have no way to protect you from people in other departments who make your life miserable.

On the On With Kara Swisher podcast, Kara Swisher answered a listener’s question about working with a jerk. The listener asked if they should leave, complain, or try to lead a revolt. Swisher replied:

I don't think leading a revolt is a very good idea. It's not your business. If they want to operate that way, that's the way they're going to operate.

And I used to sort of wallow in gripery. And I don't think that works very much in life. I think it makes you unhappy, and they don't care. And it actually, your work suffers for it.

And so I always leave.

I spent a portion of my career working with very toxic colleagues. And even though my boss was great, I realized that leadership was allowing toxicity to continue rather than address it. That says a lot about what leadership prioritizes, and it makes for a very unhealthy workplace.

3. The company is struggling

Great leadership and great products don’t always make for a successful company. Some may not have the resources to match what competitors offer, or falls behind in the market.

The economy will always have ups and downs, and some companies can weather the storm. But if it looks like the company is in trouble, you should not go down with a sinking ship. Your boss may have zero ability to save you.

Not all companies are transparent about their financial situations. You can look for signs, such as:

• Slowed sales
• A hiring freeze
• Budget cuts
• Customer complaints

You may also feel the pressure through increased micromanagement because your boss's boss wants everyone to be as productive as possible when times are tough.

4. Your career can’t grow, even with your boss's support

Depending on the organization's hierarchy, there's only so much your boss can do.

You may want career growth and are caught in the company's red tape. You can't get promoted or upskill in your current role — and there's no way for your boss to help you. Even if your boss sees your value, your career might stagnate if it's not recognized by the rest of the company.

If you've been in the same role for years without meaningful skill development or a real path forward, that's its own version of a job that isn't working. A supportive manager doesn't substitute for career growth.

The Most Important Thing In Your Career Is Your Time

Work a lot. Or a little. As long as it’s up to you.

Building SoloAnna Burgess Yang

How to evaluate a new opportunity

If you get along with your boss and things don't feel that bad, how do you know that the job is worth leaving? Taking on a new job is a risk, absolutely. You could end up in a similar situation, or (even worse) end up with a terrible boss.

Here are some things to do as you start a job search:

Treat the interview like a two-way street. You're interviewing the new boss as much as they're interviewing you. Come prepared with your own questions, such as "How do you measure success in this role?" or "How do you plan to support me during onboarding?"

Check Glassdoor. Employee reviews usually paint a fairly accurate picture of the company overall, especially factors like leadership and work-life balance. You can also use LinkedIn to find current or former employees and send a quick DM, which helps when Glassdoor is thin on reviews for smaller companies.

Run the new company through the same evaluation you give your current employer. Do as much research as you can with publicly available information. Look at the products, who's in charge, and what the growth opportunities are.

If the environment itself is what's pushing you out, it's worth knowing the signs of a toxic work environment so you don't land somewhere with the same problems you’re currently experiencing.

Prioritize yourself, not loyalty to your boss

Loyalty to your boss is admirable, and a good relationship goes a long way. But you should always put yourself first. The company will always put itself first, no matter how much your boss may try to protect you.

For many people, the hardest part of leaving a job with a good boss is the guilt that comes with it. A truly good boss will want you to do what's best for you. Ask them to be a reference or write a LinkedIn recommendation. If they get upset that you're moving on, the relationship was only ever about the work.

Thinking about a career change? Check out this free guide.

Download

Why people make the mistake of staying too long at a job

• They prioritize comfort over career growth. A tolerable routine isn't a fulfilling role. If the only reason you're staying is that the days aren't terrible, that's inertia.
• They assume their boss will always be there. Good bosses leave too. If the one thing keeping you at the company walks out the door, you're left without a buffer.
• They let loyalty override their own career goals. You shouldn't sacrifice your career trajectory for your boss.
• They're waiting for the company to change. Most companies that need to change don't. If the problems have been the same for a year or more, they're probably not going to change.

FAQs